Today we’d like to introduce you to Anthony Scalia.
Hi Anthony, we’d love for you to start by introducing yourself.
My parents owned a video store (pre-Blockbuster) and gave me a hi8 camera when I was nine years old, so I grew up watching and making films. After graduating from Ramapo College with a concentration in filmmaking, I began searching for local, New Jersey stories that I could tell. One night, hidden in plain sight, I stumbled upon the historic Bendix Diner. The diner’s owner, John Diakakis introduced himself to me as a blind, single father who also served as a full-time waiter. It wasn’t long before I was back at the diner, camera in hand, to document one of the most inspirational people I’d ever met. I worked on that short documentary, Bendix: Site Unseen, almost singlehandedly, for over three years. To my surprise, it was screened at some of the most prolific film festivals on the East Coast, including DOCNYC, the Sidewalk Film Festival and the Montclair Film Festival, where it won several awards, including “Best Short Film.”
I followed up my short documentary with the most difficult and rewarding project I’ve ever worked on – an eight episode true-crime podcast, entitled, “Denise Didn’t Come Home.” The podcast centers around the 1969 murder of a young girl named Denise Falasca, who was killed right next to my hometown. I discovered the case in 2017 when it was still unsolved and reached out to the victim’s surviving sister, Karen, who I developed a close friendship with. One night, Karen informed me that Denise’s murder had been recently solved with a confession from New Jersey’s most infamous serial killer, Richard Cottingham. However, Karen did not believe Cottingham’s confession and decided to speak with the serial killer directly in order to seek peace. Sadly, within months of their correspondence, Karen was diagnosed with terminal cancer and passed away shortly after. I was left without my friend, and without answers to her lifelong questions. So I developed a dialogue with the infamous serial killer myself, and after seven years of reporting on the story, discovered secrets that had long been hidden, revealing the truth of what actually happened on that fateful night back in 1969. The podcast was produced in partnership with my storytelling heros, Truth Media (Producers of HBO’s The Jinx and Gimlet’s Crimetown) and was distributed by Sony Music Entertainment. It went on to become the #1 series on Apple Podcasts.
I am currently working on a documentary about indigenous women in Bolivia, as well as actively uncovering more of Cottingham’s murders that are currently unsolved.
I’m sure it wasn’t obstacle-free, but would you say the journey has been fairly smooth so far?
From filming documentaries with subjects and crews that have lost interest to trying to out-wit a serial killer face-to-face in his jail cell, I can’t say that any road I’ve ever taken has been smooth. Different levels of your career come with different challenges and internal pressures. However, these are blessings in disguise – they mean that you are evolving and progressing.
However, I don’t believe artists should seek “smooth” roads, as those are often the least interesting and rewarding. Do not ignore the anxiety, pain and exhaustion that often comes with your passion, find a way to channel it back into the art. Every project I’ve ever done has been better because I spent nights crying at my laptop – otherwise that would have meant I didn’t care enough to get it as close to perfection as I possibly could. Doubt yourself a little bit, it will keep you on your toes.
As you know, we’re big fans of you and your work. For our readers who might not be as familiar what can you tell them about what you do?
I’m a documentary filmmaker and investigative journalist. The two projects I detailed above, “Bendix: Site Unseen” and “Denise Didn’t Come Home”, were both labors of love that took a collective ten years to complete. I enjoy all aspects of the creative process but interviewing and editing are my favorites. I’m most proud of the fact that my podcast was able to focus on the human side of a true crime story. My genuine friendship with Karen, and her struggles with acceptance and grief, spoke to many listeners from around the world. After the project was released, I received many kind notes from other victim’s family members, police officers and everyday listeners about how the project was a healing tool for their own grief. We turned something bad into something good. It was the one time in my life that I felt I had truly made a difference in the world.
Who else deserves credit in your story?
I consider myself extremely lucky to have been surrounded by a large network of friends and family, who have constantly supported my inconvenient and crazy passion. Nicholas Blair has been a father figure to me, teaching me not only how to be a better storyteller, but a better person. Ujval and Sonali Dalal taught me how to use a camera and put up with all of my incessant requests to film with their equipment. Their son, Urmil Dalal, has been attached to every project I’ve ever done, and is more of a brother than a colleague. His vision is consistently flawless and nuanced, and he understands the creative process at a level that many do not. Greg Buracker, another NJ filmmaker, has been my support system for the past five years – the only other person I know who does it for the love of the game. Marc Smerling is my storytelling hero, and the lessons that I continue to learn from him, to this day, are among the most valuable I’ve ever received. Ryan Sweikert is a brilliant storyteller, and someone who is able to effortlessly present the truth, while preserving the humanity. My wife, Ilsen, is the best documentary producer I’ve ever worked with and my ultimate adventure partner. My mother, Dina, and brother Jim have been there for everything. However, the most influential person in my life has been my father, Jimmy Scalia, who blazed the trail that I now walk. Without his passion and belief in me, I may have never touched a camera – and I’m happy to live out the dreams he once shared.
Contact Info:
- Website: https://www.anthonyscalia.com/
- Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/ant_scalia/





